Fair fantasy baseball trade?

Question

i'm the commissioner of a league and i also review trades to make sure they're fair to pass through. some team is getting derrek lee for brian giles, konerko, and howie kendrick. is this fair? i don't think so.

Answer 1

baseball is boring

Answer 2

Well whoever is giving up Derrek Lee is gettting ripped off obviously, but its not that ridiculous that you should veto the whole trade. Whats happening is the person is getting worried since Derrek Lee is one of the elite leaders in homeruns but thats because he hasnt gotten hot yet which he probably will.In my leagues we only do that for really crappy trades. ex--  Trading Alex Rodriguez for Howie Kendrick.

So bottom Line Allow the Trade

Answer 3

It definitely favors the side getting Derrek Lee, but it's not outrageously unfair.

Lee is by far the best player in the deal. He's been streaky, but has 35 HR power. Konerko should be the next best player, but he's having a very bad year. Kendrick is a big injury risk, and Giles isn't good at all, unless this league counts OBP. The only reason I would take the side with Kendrick is if I desperately needed a 2B. Maybe you should take a vote of the league to see whether or not it should be vetoed.