Fair trade?

Question

ill get donovan mcnabb, javon walker, n ravens defense they get eli manning, brandon marshall n eagles defense

Answer 1

Are you kidding me?  That's a terrible trade for you.

1.  Manning is way better than McNabb, who may not start the whole season (he's under a lot of pressure)

2.  Marshall is in a better situation than Walker.  Raiders have no QB, and they are still the WORST team in the NFL = no fantasy points.  Marshall has Cutler to get him lots of opportunities.

3.  Both of those defenses are worthless right now in fantasy, so it doesn't matter.

Answer 2

Youre getting ripped off if you take that trade.

Donovan "Hobbles" McNabb is due for another injury. Javon Walker is already injured, and the Ravens D is just a bonus.

Meanwhile, Eli just won a super bowl, Marshall is coming off a breakout season, and the eagles D, again, bonus.

dont do it. dont even consider it.

Answer 3

Well you are getting a good deal. McNabb is a very talented QB way better than Eli hopefully McNabb can stay injury free. Make sure you have a good back up QB. Good move getting Marshall over Walker. Brandon is a talent hopefully Jay Cutler and find him in the endzone. Walker is a blue chip it depends on how we fits into the Raider offense and how he clicks with JaMarrcus Russell. Ravens defense has been slowing down of late but still respectable. Eagles defense might be a bit better with their tenancity. But Overall you got the better deal. Good luck on making a run for the championship.

Answer 4

Eli and Donovan are even if Mcnabb stays healthy

Marshall is way better than walker

eagles and ravens defense  d does not really matter in fantasy