Fansaty footballl help rate this from 1 to 10?

Question

vince young

stephen jackson

lendale white

braylon edwards

brandon marshalls

darren mcfadden

alge crumpler

titans d

rob birnos

bench

clavin johnson

jamarcus russel

donald lee

roydell willams

chris johnson

ted ginn jr

leaon washing ton

and can some of u give me some advice on some change

Answer 1

Ouch - if this is a 12+ team league, I think it's OK, but if not, I'm sorry but I'd have to give it a 4-5... too many question marks!

(Lendale White, Darren McFadden, Crumpler, even Young! Plus Russell and others...)

Again, sorry man - just needs more balance throughout!

Answer 2

Positional breakdown:

QB - Iffy.  Young knows how to win games, but he's a much better real-life QB than a fantasy QB.  I wouldn't want him as my starting QB.  Russel has a lot of talent, so you better hope Javon Walker is worth what they're paying him.  McFadden should also help...he's talented enough to take a dump pass for a TD, but...Russel's still unproven in my book.  I'd look to upgrade if you can.  

RB - I like it.  Jackson is in stud territory, and White is a good RB2.  McFadden is a wildcard, but if he can do half of what Adrian Peterson did as a rookie, then hes going to be a heck of a value at RB3.  

WR - Nice.  Edwards is a top-5 talent, and Marshall could end the season top-10, though with recent legal issues he may be suspended for some of the season.  Hopefully he'll grow up some and you'll have him come playoff time, and you have a nice WR corps.  

TE - Functional.  Nothing special, I'm a little worried that you're depending too much on the Titans (Young, Alge, and DEF) but so be it, that happens.  I wouldn't be disappointed with Alge, especially given the rest of your team.  

DEF - Good D, should be fine there.  

K - Who cares?

Bench: Lee has potential to score points; often a pass-catching TE becomes a young QB's best friend; Rodgers may look to him as a dump-off option.  Johnson is extremely talented and will fill in fine when you need him to; even if Marshall is suspended you have a good backup.  The rest...eh, nothing spectacular, but it's the bench.  If you can upgrade at QB, I would try to, but on a scale from 1-10, given your RB depth (I like the Watson pick up, by the way), I'd give you a 7.5-8.