Fantasy Baseball: Adam Dunn for Ichiro Suzuki, should I do the deal?

Question

I am in a head to head ten team keeper league which uses these stats R, H, 3B, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OBP, W, CG, SHO, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, K/BB.

My current Roster

C Ivan Rodriguez

1B Justin Morneau

2B Ian Kinsler

3B Kevin Youkilis

SS Ryan Theriot

OF Adam Dunn

OF Ryan Ludwick

OF Pat Burrell

Util Corey Hart

BN Shane Victorino

BN Xavier Nady

BN Chipper Jones

SP Johan Santana

SP Cliff Lee

SP Ryan Dempster

SP Jeremy Guthrie

SP Shaun Marcum

SP Jorge Campillo

SP Scott Baker

RP Joe Nathan

RP Troy Percival

RP Jon Rauch

Another owner has offered me Ichiro Suzuki for Adam Dunn. Should I do this deal?

Answer 1

As much as i love ichiro i would stick with dunn because your roster doesn't look like it has a ton of pop

Answer 2

One thing you have to ask yourself is do I want consistent production, or big numbers coupled with a low avg. Once you get that down, i think you know who to pick.

Overall I think it is pretty much even, but i would favor Dunn slightly because of the huge homer numbers.

Your choice

Hope i could help

PS i would drop Rauch since he is now a set up man, and maybe pick up Randy Johnson if available