Fantasy Baseball Keeper League trade?

Question

Should I deal Pedroia and Gallardo for Bobby Abreu and Jose Valverde...

I have Utley playing second so Pedroia is my Util bat...

Answer 1

If this is a keeper league, I say no. Pedroia's a young player who will eventually be a superstar when he's around 30. Gallardo's even younger and will become a potential Cy Young winner. Abreu is old and won't get any better. Valverde is young, is a closer, so isn't worth as much as Gallardo. Even though you have Utley, it's not worth getting rid of two superstars for two aging players.

Answer 2

No...if this is a keeper league then pedroia needs to be kept and gallardo has shown he can really be a great pitcher when he is healthy and valverde is iffy.