Fantasy Baseball Trade: I get Adam Dunn and Jamie Shields, and give up Justin Morneau.?

Question

Should I accept that trade? By getting Dunn, I'll have to bench one of my OF (Ankiel, Burrell, Hamilton, Taveras). I want Shields, because I need to improve in ERA and WHIP, but I'm afraid I might be giving up too much (taking into account that I'll have to pick up a 1B, and the free agents options are not good).

Answer 1

You probably shouldn't. Morneau is too much to give up and Shields isn't the best pitcher to get to improve ERA and WHIP. Ask for more than that.

Answer 2

no morneau just one the homerun derby

Answer 3

Definitely not...

Morneau is one of the best second-half players in the game.

He was on fire going into the A.S.B....

Answer 4

Yeah, I second the no, pitchers get hot, but these players will probably stand, Morneau has been doing good, just watch the era of some free agents.

Answer 5

I vote no.  Morneau is a fantasy stud.