Fantasy Baseball Trade - Who Wins?

Question

Chase Utley and Tori Hunter for Cliff Lee, Jermaine Dye, Howie Kendrick and Cris Carpenter.

The league is a Roto league and permits an unlimited amount of players on the DL (thus Carpenter involved) but only 2 reserve players.

Thank you so much for the help!

Answer 1

This is not a good trade for the side giving up Utley. Be aware that most 3-1,4-2 deals are not. Remember that in this deal even with Carpenter going to the DL, there still has to be one player dropped. That player needs to be considered a part of the deal also.

Good luck. Have fun.

Answer 2

Carpenter? If he comes back this year, he will likely be a middle reliever. So you can pretty much scratch him out of this equation. That said, I think I like the Utley/Hunter side better.

Answer 3

definitly the guy getting utley and cliff lee kendrick is doing nothing carpenter probably will barely play at all this season and cliff lee never gets run support  and is going to start losing alot more games