Fantasy Baseball Trade???

Question

I give up Edison volquez and I get Ian Kinsler....should I do it???

This is a 15 keeper league.

Answer 1

I guess it depends on how much other pitching you have to keep. Kinsler is a young very good second baseman and if you need that position filled for the future I'd do it.

Kinsler is also in a very talented lineup and Volquez is on a horrible team.

Answer 2

in a keeper league it's tough. it really depends on your needs. if you're pitching is solid then yes..if not then dont do it.

Answer 3

no kinsler slowed after the break last year and i still havent seen volquez throw a ball letter high so u know he will be consistant and a center for your team

Answer 4

Do it.  Kinsler is producing at a somewhat weak position while starting pitchers are much easier to replace.  Volquez will have his rough starts and its much more difficult to predict a pitcher into the future.  Kinsler will likely be the better keeper for that reason.

Answer 5

you have a competitve league obviously with 15 people in it. The main thing is if your pitching can give up a stud like volquez and still be good then you should definitely do it. assuming you need hitting kinsler will help for sure