Fantasy Baseball trade question?

Question

Which side would you rather take in a standard roto league (12 teams). I was offered Calos Beltran and Tim Hudson for Mariano Rivera and Adam Wainwright.

My team looks like this:

C-Ivan Rodriguez

1b: Marcus Thames

2b: Ryan Theriot

3b: Miguel Cabrera

SS: Jeter

OF: Ichiro

OF: Nate Mclouth

OF: Curtis Granderson

UT: Hawpe

BN: Loney

BN: Alexi Ramirez

DL: Vernon Wells

SP: Peavy

SP: Haren

RP: Mariano Rivera

RP: Lyons

P: BJ Ryan

P: Mike Gonzalez (ATL)

P: Buehrle

BN: Verlander

BN: Carpenter (DL)

BN: Wainwright (DL)

Answer 1

Don't do it.I know wainwright is on the DL,but you're other releivers are wastes, plus you have a great outfield so you don't need Beltran.Keep Mo.Don't do It.

Answer 2

Don't. Lyon is about to be given up the closers role since Rauch is now on the D-Backs and Gonzalez hasn't closed much, so if you trade Rivera, then you'll have one closer left (Ryan). You also have a good outfield and Beltran won't help you too much, except taking away another closer.