Fantasy Football Keeper Help!!?

Question

I am in a keeper league and we need to keep 3 players. My list of keepers is due today. I am only allowed to keep 3 and then have to be from different positions. I have two already selected, but I am having trouble with my third. Should I choose a RB from below or Kellen Winslow to keep???

Jones, Kevin RB CHI

McGahee, Willis RB BAL

Winslow, Kellen TE CLE

Brown, Ronnie RB MIA

Smith, Musa RB NYJ

The other two I kept were Roethlisberger, Ben QB PIT and Owens, Terrell WR DAL , now I need a third from the above list....

Answer 1

keep winslow

Answer 2

i think it would have to be mcGahee just because the browns added stallworth and i dont think they can repeat from last year. and the ravens will be running alot because of there qb situation and how young they are

Answer 3

I would probably keep mcgahee. I really like winslow but if you think about it, when will he be drafted next year? 5th-6th round at the earliest most likely. Mcgahee would be drafted in probably the 2nd-3rd round. I like Mcgahee a little better than ronnie brown at the moment, but I think you do need to keep a RB

Answer 4

I'd keep either McGahee or Winslow.

Answer 5

that's a really tough decision. i'm really torn between brown, winslow and magahee. my advice to you is this, if you keep brown don't wait too long to draft ricky williams. he has looked great this preseason, so much so that there is talk of trading ronnie brown. i don't know if it will go that far though. if you keep magahee make sure you pick up ray rice. he has looked pretty good this year too. the plus side of the b-more guys is they play the terrible browns and bengals defenses twice. winslow will put up great numbers but i don't know if you can afford to go into the draft without a rb kept. it's a very tough decision.

Answer 6

I would say keep McG and pick up Winslow in the first or second round of your draft.  Doubtful that he will be gone by then, but there is a high chance McG would be gone.

Answer 7

Keep McGahee. Brown is horrible and is on the Dolphins (will lose to to Williams in the coing years) and a TE is not worth keeping, there will always be good TE's to take.

Answer 8

I would keep winslow.  he is a game-winning TE.  McGahee and Brown are not really game-winning RB, you can draft a few players of their caliber or one of the rookie RB's could emerge...