Fantasy Football: McFadden vs. Turner vs. Edge?

Question

Which one would you rather have for your RB3 slot: Darren McFadden (Oak), Michael Turner (Atl), or Edgerrin James (Ari)?

My other 2 RBs are Clinton Portis and Willis McGahee.

Thanks

Answer 1

Turner, easliy.  He had something like a 4.5 ypc with the Chargers.

Give him a shot.

Answer 2

Micheal Turner, no doubt. Atlanta's surely going to utilize him this year.

Answer 3

For week 1 I'd give it to Edge or Turner...with Edge getting the edge. because Ariz is playing SF and Atl is playing Det...Ariz has a better, more productive offense (at least when Warner is playing).  I have a feeling Atl will be playing catchup and trying to win thru the air in week 1

Answer 4

I think you need to change out Turner and Edge and see who is playing th e weaker team. McFadden is a diamond in the rough. i really haven't heard alot of him in the preseason which tells me he's not getting the in game reps. Keep an eye on him. He could be a real sleeper. Turner is not an every down back. Durability may be his real question mark. He's going to be doing alot of the work and he really hasnt' done it before.