Fantasy Football TRADE...HELP!!!!!!!!!?

Question

My Team--

Payton Manning-QB

Plaxico Burress-WR

Santonio Holmes-WR

Marion Barber-RB

Fred Taylor-RB

Dallas Clark-TE

Laveranues Coles-W/T

Bench-

Reggie Brown-wr

Thomas Jones-RB

Willis MaGahee-RB

Donte Stallworth-WR

My Trade is:

Ryan Grant-RB for my Magahee and Thomas Jones

MaGaee had his Surgery and said to be avaliable to play but my not be n e good for first couple of weeks...beings its a KNEE surgery im skeptic about him...SHOULD I MAKE THE TRADE FOR RYAN GRANT!!!?!?!?!?!?!

HELP ME AND Y SHOULD I PLEASE!!!!!!!

Answer 1

I think thomas jones and ryan grant will end up with similar numbers so I would keep willis for when he comes back

Answer 2

Just remember Ryan Grant thrived in in offense that loved to pass and did it well. They also put up a lot of points which allowed them to run more in the second half.  Defenses pretty much gave Grant free reign so they wouldn't get burned by the passing attack of GB.  With Aaron Rogers at QB and the fact that Ryan Grant had a good year last year most teams will probably load up the box and make GB throw the ball atleast until Rogers proves himself.  I don't see Ryan Grant having anywhere near as good of a year as he had last year. It is the complete opposite for T. Jones. He has a revitalized offensive line and a QB who probably wont do as good as he normally does but still have a good enough years where teams will not load up against the run. I would keep T. Jones and play him until Mcgahee gets back and maybe even keep him in afterwards

Answer 3

Ryan Grant is the feature back in his offense, and guaranteed to get yards and TDs.  

Thomas Jones was just plain bad last year, and has Leon Washington stealing carries, and McGahee doesn't get goal line carries and is coming off knee surgery.  

I'd say take the trade.  Better to have one good player than two mediocre ones

Answer 4

I have McGahee on my fantasy team too....I just read that he may be out for the next 2 to 4 weeks to recover fully. I don't know about you but I'm trading!

Answer 5

don't do it.  how can you trade grant (not a good QB and average line) for two decent RB's?  Favre will help thomas jones.  McGahee will be fine.  Instead of trading, you should go pick up Ray Rice if you're that concerned about Mcgahee

Answer 6

No, Grant might be a one hit wonder and isn't worth two runningbacks.  

Answer 7

dont trade!!

i doubt grant will have a good impact on your team

i think willis wuld be better

just wait for him to recover

Answer 8

i think getting grant would be a good move.