Fantasy Football - Who got the better of each trade?

Question

Two trades I made recently in a fantasy league that just autodrafted for everyone. Basic yahoo format league: 12 teams, H2H. Not saying which side is mine so no bias can be inputted. Thanks to anyone who comments on which side of

each trade got the better, then I'll know if I made good trades.

1st trade:

Team 1 gets:

Jerricho Cotchery (NYJ - WR)

&

Shaun Suisham (Was - K)

Team 2 gets:

Marvin Harrison (Ind - WR)

&

Tarvaris Jackson (Min - QB)

2nd trade:

Team 3 gets:

Nate Burleson (Sea - WR)

&

Edgerrin James (Ari - RB)

&

Alge Crumpler (Ten - TE)

Team 4 gets:

Fred Taylor (Jac - RB)

&

Aaron Rodgers (GB - QB)

&

Justin Gage (Ten - WR)

Answer 1

I think teams 2 and 4 got the better of those. on trade 2, Eddie James is a big time question mark, and Fred Taylor has a good chance to be a great sleeper pick-up.  A. Rodgers and a GREAT upside to have a heck of season BUT also has be shoes to fill.  I don't think the GB WR's will let him fail though.

I hope you will tell us which one's you picked up.

Answer 2

team 3 got the best and one question why is someone trading a kicker they mean nothign especially that one

Answer 3

Trade #1 goes to team #2

Trade #2 goes to team #3

Answer 4

1st trade: Team 2 gets the better end of the deal. I wouldn't even count the kicker. You can always pick up a solid kicker off the free agent list. They carry no real value. That said, it's basically Cotchery for Harrison and Jackson. No one knows what will happen with Harrison, but I'd still take him over Cotchery. Also, Jackson has a lot of potential.

2nd trade: That's a tough one. It's pretty even. I'd probably say team 3 gets the better end of the deal. Burleson should have a bigger role this season and put up better numbers than Justin Gage. I'd take James over Taylor, too. SImply put, MJD will steal carries from Taylor. James will be the man in Arizona. Finally, I'd rather have Rodgers over Crumpler. TEs don't carry much value. Like Jackson, there's a lot of potential there with Rodgers in that passing offense. Good luck!