Fantasy Football trade before season starts?

Question

Should I trade Eli Manning and Larry Johnson for Marc Bulger and Marion Barber?

I like Eli better than Bulger but everyone is saying that you should trade LJ while he is still worth something. Should I do this? and why?

Answer 1

If the other guy is willing, I say go for it. Barber has a nose for the endzone and you've got to like his potential over LJ. Also, Bulger should bounce back this season and put up good number with an improved offensive line and coordinator in Al Saunders. Good luck!

Answer 2

DO IT!!!!!  

Answer 3

Depends of the rest of your roster. I like Eli way better than Bulger. personally I think Bulger will get hurt again. However Larry johnson is overrated if you ask me. Just looking at it I would do it because I think Barber will be great this season

Answer 4

I would say yes. I like Bulger better than Eli. and Barber better than LJ. Eli stills gets flustered and throws picks. FFToolbox.com also predicts Eli will be a bust this year. Barber is a great back and should get more yards with J. Jones in Sea. I would pay attention to bye weeks though and not trade for people who have the same bye week as the rest of your team.  

Answer 5

This is a tough trade because you will get one great player and one that might be at best ok.  Eli is going to break out and Bulger is not going to play for more then half the season because he'll get hurt again.  Barber is on a better team then LJ.  LJ will be on a team that is a Run First second pass because KC doesn't have a QB.  So Eli over Bulger, Barber over LJ but I believe Eli will give you more points then Barber the 2 best in this Trade SO Dont trade I just think if Eli is your starting QB you need it.

Answer 6

They are about as even as could be. The Giants will try as hard as they can to keep the  ball on the ground, but Eli will still throw some TDs. Bulger doesn't have the weapons he once had and Jackson will put up 15 tds this year. Barber will be productive but the Cowboys like to throw early and often, especially in the redzone so he may not score alot, although he is capable of 15tds himself. LJ is still LJ, and the Chiefs still have no passing attack. Toss up if you ask me, but id say Barber is the most definite producer of the 4.

LJ IS NOTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT Overrated. By no means. The man is a tank. A stud. A monster. He will have 1300 and 12tds as long as he is healthy. The man can take pain, he will be a beast once again this year. Anyone who says Johnson is overrated is a moron and should be slapped in the face. Idiot.