Fantasy Football trade offer?

Question

Which is better and please explain why

Wes Welker, Darren McFadden

Marques Colston, Edgerrin James

Answer 1

Colston and James.  Both proven.  McFadden will definatley share a lot of time in Oak. and Oak. will Have to throw a lot.  Colston is ranked in the top 10.  

Answer 2

Colston for James make me want to cry. You'd have to be really desperate to make that trade.

Welker for McFadden is more resonable, if this is not a PPR league. If it is then it's again a lopsided trade.

Edit: Maybe I'm reading this wrong. If it's Welker and McFadden for Colston and James then that's not too bad at all. The one getting Colston and James has the better deal imo.

Answer 3

Marques Colston or Wes Welker its a toss up. They both play in passing offenses, there numbers are compariable, but Colston is bigger and usually scores more touchdowns(12 to 8 last year). Edgerrin James is old and his ypc have gone down every year. darren McFadden will be good but the raiders will limit his work load this year he has never been a full time back(felix jones at arkansas split time), and Fargas had 1000 yards last year and is a much better pass blocker so he is going to get some touches

Answer 4

colston and james. mcfadden will probably have equal value to edge but he will have big games here and there while edge will consistent post decent numbers. but the difference is in colston. colston is in a contract year and with addition of shockey, he will get more open. welker was a 1year wonder in my opinion. i definitely go with colston/james.