Fantasy QB help who should i pick?

Question

okay i get 60 per TD

1 point per yard he throws out

i can get eli manning

david garrard

jon kitna

philip rivers aaron rodgers

alex smith

jason campbell

jamarcus russell

trent edwards

please give reasons tanx

Answer 1

1 Kitna - has great receivers with a new found running game to keep the D honest, should have a solid year

1 1/2 Garrard- close second because of his persision he wont throw the ints and has above average WR and the ability to scramble

3 Rivers couls have a big year with chambers and jackson, knee worries me 0 scramble ability

4 rodgers - has a lot to prove but has the receivers and scrabling ability to score a lot of points

5 Campbell - has all the potential in the world, could start slow but has a lot of upside with moss and el along with the two big Rookies and Cooley at TE

6 Manning - too many bad games to rely on

7 Edwards - Like campbell has the potential but i dont like the WRs

8 Russell - Could struggle, still learning to play in the NFL but has a canon for an arm which could get some hugh games

9 Smtih - would not take him, lost the starting jog to someone named JT O'sullivan yea thats bad

Answer 2

Kitna great receiving corp

Campbell as backup he has the potential to be very good

Answer 3

If it were me I'd axe Smith, Russell and Edwards (bad teams make for tough QB situations - they'll be forced to throw and I assume there are penatlyies for interceptions).

Past that, I have to ask if QBs get points for rushing yards because Garrard and Campbell are good solid picks...if and only if they also get points for their scrambling abilities.

Otherwise, I might go with Rivers. he's got a great team and he can dump the ball to LT and get a lot of yards in the air without breaking much of a sweat.