Fantasy: Ryan Grant or Willis McGahee

Question

I'm in a holdover fantasy football league and I get to holdover three players. I'm holding Reggie Wayne and Frank Gore but I can't decide on Grant or McGahee for the third. What do yall think?

Answer 1

Grant.

If the Ravens were thrilled with what McGahee was doing for them...they would not have drafted Ray Rice in the 2nd round.  Reports out of camp are very encouraging on Rice.  I expect him to see time and usually take him with my last pick in drafts.  

Answer 2

McGahee.

He will get a higher percentage of their offense.

He will get the short passes too.

Answer 3

im a grant fan..go packers!!

Answer 4

They are rated neck-and-neck.

They both have the same problems, having a "rookie" QB.  Baltimore will likely go with Flacco, or Troy Smith.

Aaron Rodgers has not been a starter, though he's been behind Favre which is good on the job training.

Grant is younger, and has a better line.

Jonathan Ogden retired in Baltimore, and Baltimore has a tougher schedule.

Take Grant.

Answer 5

Grant. Packers have a new QB and they might be working the run a lot more often. This will be good for Grant. He had over 900 yards last year and only played half the season.

Answer 6

That's a tough one, but I would go with Ryan Grant.  The quarterback situation in Baltimore isn't the best right now, and if they don't have the ability to make a big play in passes, then the defense can focus on taking away the run.  Even with Aaron Rodgers behind the helm in Green Bay, they still will have a solid pass attack and good O-Line to keep Grant getting big numbers.

Answer 7

McGahee, Grant wont be nearly as productive with Farve out of the pictures. Good luck and have fun!