Fantasy Trade!!! 10 pts?

Question

I Get:

Peyton Manning

He Gets:

Ben Roethlisberger

Jonathan Stewart

Justin Fargas

Is this a fair trade because in my league their is only a 13 point difference between Peyton and Ben. The guy has no RBs and he wants some. And I have Reggie Wayne and Marvin Harrison which would be good for me if I get him. Is this FAIR? Why or why not?

Answer 1

Umm...no!!!

Lookit, Jonathan Stewart has a lot of upside.  He should poach most of the goal line carries from that midget D. Williams.  Fargas is in a platoon situation, but he IS the starter right now.  Everyone would agree that that Manning is better than Big Ben, but he's not two RB's better.  Either drop Stewart out of the trade or make him add someone that you will actually start sometimes.

Answer 2

This is a YES, absolutely. Considering of course that you do have 2 starting RBs.

Stewart and Fargas will be sharing carries, not good for fantasy, and expect from Manning a similiar season as Brady's 2007. He wants his record (TDs in single season) back, and has the right WRs and TE to do so.