Fantasy Trade Opinion: 12 Team PPR League

Question

Team #1

Gets:

Brian Westbrook

Marques Colston

for

Team #2

Gets:

Thomas Jones

Marvin Harrison

Brandon Jacobs

Is this fair value deal or not? I'm the commish and i'm wondering if the deal is veto worthy.

----------------

PPR League settings

WR/RB/TE

10 yards = 1pt

Reception = 1pt

TD = 6pts

100 yards = 3 pt bonus

150 yards = 2pt bonus

175 yards = 3pt bonus

QB

20 Yards = 1pt

TD = 4pts

230 yards = 2pt bonus

250 yars = 1pt

300 yarss = 3pt bonus

Answer 1

Sounds like a very fair trade for both sides

Answer 2

I think Team 1 is getting a much better deal with Westbrook and Colston, especially in PPR leagues where Westbrook is ranked only below LT.

That being said, I still don't think you should veto it.

Team 1 gets the better end of the deal and they also free up a slot to pick up a sleeper candidate on the waiver. Sounds like Team 2 is banking on Harrison being back and healthy, that Favre with the new O line in Jersey will increase TJ's production this year and that Jacobs will stay healthy enough to be the TD machine for the Giants.

If both teams feel it's a fair trade and you don't hear a lot of complaints from other teams, then I say let it go though.

Answer 3

As a commish I would allow, but team A is giving away two top 5 players.  It is not a good deal for them.  But again, as commish I would allow.

If you like quarterbacks and would like to join a two starting qb league please join Yahoo Custom ID 306876 password Queen live 12 team draft Aug 12 at 7:30 pm  League name Sheephead Players OR

Fox free published league ID 65500 password 1234 live 12 team draft Aug 14 at 7:30pm.  League name Aaron Farve on Waivers.

Answer 4

yes, very fair trade.