Fantasy Trade: Team A or Team B?

Question

Team A gets

T Owens wr

J Lewis rb

Team B gets

S Moss wr

M Barber

Who gets the better of this trade?

Answer 1

This is a pretty even trade.  I like Team A's side a little more simply because I like what the Browns have been doing with their o-line as they now have a lot of talent and depth - which should give Lewis plenty of TD chances.  Also TO is still a top 5 WR.

Team B doesn't do bad in this deal either.  Barber has a chance to do a lot of damage with the Cowboys now that he has the starting gig locked up and is a late 1st round/early 2nd round type pick IMO.  S Moss is a decent WR2 or WR 3 that he should be able to use most weeks.

Overall this trade seems quite fair to me and a good case could be made for either side IMO.

Answer 2

Team A clearly!  I've had Owens on my team for 6 years and won the last 4!  He's still a top 2-3 WR.  Lewis will be the sole starter on an up-and-coming team that is becoming an offensive juggernaut.  S. Moss is injury-prone on a team that runs first and passes 2nd (to the TE).  Barber could be good this year - then again he has never averaged many carries per game and maybe Dall. stays with the platoon.

Answer 3

Team A.  TO and Lewis are both two great players.  Santana Moss slowed down last season, but on the other side marion barber is great.

Answer 4

TEam B

Answer 5

B gets the better trade all the way. Owens is good and will get some TD's but Lewis has not been spectacular or even that good the last few years. Moss is going to get just as many TD's as Owens and Barber is the go to guy now who will pound out yards and TD's he can also catch the ball out of the backfield a lot better than Lewis!