Fantasy baseball trade: Ian Kinsler for Roy Halladay?

Question

Pitching and Hitting are each given 5 categories. My hitting is all but a lock, there is only one other player in the league with a chance to take even 1 category from me in hitting. Pitching I have a legit 6 man lineup after the trade it will focus largely on ERA, Saves and Whip. If I can take one of the 5 pitching stats in a week I cant lose? Good trade or No?

Answer 1

if you get halladay  do it.

Answer 2

I would take Kinsler. Hitters are generally more valuable and Kinsler can do it all. Halladay is still struggling.