Fantasy baseball trade? Is this trade close for both sides and who wins?

Question

Team A gets A-Rod and J. Chamberlain

Team B gets M. Lowell, E. Renteria(not great but an upgrade over the current SS because of a 12 team league with deep rosters), C. Young(OF) and B. Webb.

Answer 1

assuming brandon webb turns it around, team B.

Answer 2

Interesting. I think Chamberlain is a little overrated as a starter, although who knows if he will catch fire later on in the season. It's always tough to trade A-Rod, but I think team B gets the better of the deal. I don't like getting 2 more people added to my roster because then I have to cut 2 players from my team. However, Lowell will do a good job trying to replace A-Rod's production. Webb is a top 3 pitcher in the league. It is hard to say about Renteria and Young because I don't know who team B has on their team, but if they are both upgrades, then Team B wins. Fair trade, though