Fantasy football trade!! help please!?

Question

I give: Reggie Wayne

I get: Clinton Portis

QB: Jay Cutler

QB: Marc Bulger

RB: Brian Westbrook

RB: Willie Parker

RB/WR: Roddy White

WR: Reggie Wayne

WR: Santonio Holmes

TE: Antonio Gates

D/ST: Eagles

K: Shayne Graham

B: Micheal Turner RB

B: Matt Schaub QB

B: Troy Smith QB

B: Tony Scheffler TE

B: Calvin Johnson WR

B: Bucs D/ST

Answer 1

I would so get this deal, with IND wr and Paytons knee, they will handoff more. get Portis he is a warhorse.

Answer 2

you shouldnt do this trade.  you will lose more than you are gaining.

Answer 3

Not only no, but h**l no.

Reggie Wayne is probably the best guy on your team, next to maybe Gates and Westbrook. Portis is injury prone and inconsistent. Besides, you have an elite back in Westbrook and near a top-10 RB in Turner. Parker may drop off as Rashard Mendenhall works toward being the #1 back in Pittsburgh. But, I'm just not sold on Portis, particularly for a proven consistent stud like Wayne.

Answer 4

Don't do it!  Calvin Johnson is poised for a breakout year, so you'd have 2 awesome starters without Wayne, and having Portis and Westbrook in the same backfield is amazing!

Also, I suspect there are going to be problems with the Indy offense all season long.  Peyton may end up putting up good numbers, but it's hard to tell what will happen with Marvin back.  And they've got injury issues on offfense.  

Answer 5

No you have 3 good RBs and Wyane is your only lock at WR.  Keep Wayne