Fantasy trade help!?

Question

Someone in my league wants Utley. Their initial offer wasn't good, but I'm thinking of countering with this:

I give:

Utley

Jay Bruce

Justin Duchscherer

They give:

Matt Holliday

Manny Ramirez

Huston Street

Is this a bad offer for me? I hate to part with Utley, but I think this would still be in my favor. I need saves, currently am on top in ERA.

Also, OBP counts in my league.

Answer 1

Do not make that trade. I know Jay Bruce is struggling but Chase Utley is arguably the best fantasy baseball player in the league besides Alex Rodriguez. Justin has a good ERA and Huston Street is injury prone. Manny is good but he's no Chase Utley as far as fantasy numbers are concerned.

Answer 2

That is a very good trade for you, especially if you need saves and OBP. Manny and Holliday will help you greatly.

Answer 3

He is not going to accept that unless he is desprate.  You get a lot in that trade.