Fantasy trade question?

Question

yeaah usually i dont do this but im stuck

i have michael turner

steve smith(carolina)

and san diego D

and he is proposing

dwayne bowe

willis mcgahee

and jacksonville D

i also have colts D on the bench just in case

i really need a good runningback but idk if losing san diego D and steve smith is worth it

2 hours ago

Answer 1

if i were u, i would trade turner and colts d for mcgahee and jacksonville D.

good luck!! hope i helped!

Answer 2

Don't underestimate Dwayne Bowe. He looked very good as a rookie last season and now with more experience under his belt he could break out. Steve Smith on the other hand is getting older, has been beat up the last couple of years, and will be suspended in the first two games for punching a teamate. Also I'm not so sure that the Jaguars defense is that far behind the Chargers. The decision is yours but I'd go for it.

Answer 3

that is fair but mcgahee is a high risk player he is injury prone and didnt play great last year

I would look for a similar trade but with a different running back who is more consistent

Answer 4

I say no. I have a weird hunch about Turner this year.  Smith is a high risk WR, but still a better option the Bowe.  San Diego D will offset.  The trade is almost even.  Just hold on to Turner.  At least that is what I would do and I am pretty successful at FFB.  I rarely trade because a successful player makes the best out of his draft and relies on nice picks on the waiver wire as the season progresses.  Always pay attention to injury reports and player emergence.  An experienced FFB player knows that the draft gets you started and you do not have the same team by the end of the season.  You want a RB? Look for potential sleepers.  I picked up Roddy White, Earnest Graham, and Ryan Grant.  Paying attention pays.  I was considered the Juggernaut that could not be beaten.  Don't worry bro, you will find those players.  

This might help.  Pay attention to Duece McAllister.  He will not hold up and Pierre Thomas will move in to take his spot.  Ricky Williams has done well and Ronnie Brown is still feeling the pain from the ACL surgery.  Rudi Johnson has that hamstring nagging him again.  Look for Kenny Watson or Chris Perry.  The potential to pick up a great player is still open game.

Good luck.

Thumbs up to those who agree.

Answer 5

No. McGahee does not have good conditioning skills, making him injury prone. Turner is a good RB.

Turner>McGahee

Smith>Bowe (except first 3 weeks)

SD>JAC

Answer 6

hey d h mcgahee played extremely well last season, and with his behemoth offensive line i expect another great season, but mcgahee is not a number 1 back and he is not much better than turner. Granted, Turner is unproven, I am expecting an 1100 yard season with 8 TDs which is not much worse than Mcgahee but that trade might be worth it bc Steve Smith will not play 2 games in the season and Dwayne Bowe is an up-and-coming reciever.