Favourable Trade?

Question

David Garrard, Terrel Owens and Anthony Gonzalez (him) for LaDainian Tomlinson and Braylon Edwards (me)

I have Marc Bulger as my QB and Rudi Johnson and Fred Taylor as my RBs, also i have Joey Galloway as my WR

Answer 1

The side that gets LT & Edwards definitely gets the better side of the deal.

Answer 2

You getting edwards and LT is nice but I would keep Garrard as the starter and dump the oft injured and way over rated Bulger in the deal

Answer 3

No. This isn't a good trade for you. You're trading away arguably the best RB and a top-3 WR for an average QB, top-3 WR and an unproven WR. T.O. and Braylon will put up similar numbers. That said, I wouldn't trade LT for Garrard and Gonzo. Bulger should bounce back this season. If I were you, I'd try trading Rudi or Fred Taylor for Gonzo, straight up. Good luck!