Fedor VS. Anderson Silva?

Question

Who do you think would win this match!? I was VERY impressed by both their performances tonight. More so Fedor , I hope people know now why all that hype is around him. Who do you think would win If Fedor and Anderson Silva met in a fight , at their natural weights.

Answer 1

This isn't even a hypothetical.  Fedor would demolish Anderson Silva and it's not because he's a more skilled fighter.  Silva looked great tonight but keep in mind that he had to pick up 21 pounds from where he normally fights.  The notion that he could pick ANOTHER 20 some pounds up AND defend his middleweight (185) title is absurd.  

P.S. Silva's natural weight is like 190.  I'm sure the 45 pound advantage would assure Fedor the win.

Answer 2

A tough question, many would say that fedor would win because of his size and his record.  But I believe that even with a tarnished record, silva has evolved into a remarkable fighter at the present.  And remember that silva walks around at 215 anyway.  They are both very poised fighters.  Well, I think silva has the potential to beat fedor, he would just have to get used to  fighting bigger opponents.  Fedor has a definite potential to beat silva, he just has no room to slip up.  that said any fighter can lose, u would just have to watch and see.

Answer 3

This will never happen...b./c of one thing (yes "thing")...Dana White. He will not allow any of his fighters to fight in other promotions or co-promotions. But if it does happen, Fedor will definitely dominate Silva. Fedor has fought much bigger fighters and is well rounded in stand up and the ground. He will just be too powerful for Silva. Silva is quick but Fedor will is deceptively quick for his size and he will definitely overpower Silva. If it its standing TKO combo will kill Silva. On the ground, I see Fedor with a Rear Naked Choke or Armbar or worst (for Silva) a ground and pound beating.

Answer 4

ANDERSON SILVA WOULD KILL FEDOR!!!! in an alternate universe............they actually had to create a 3rd universe for silva, fedor beat him in universe 2 also.....

Answer 5

their natural weights are actually much closer than people realize

fedor weighs in, walks around at, and fights at roughly 230

anderson silva weighs in at 185, however walking around and during his fights he weighs about 220, he's actually bigger than a lot of light heavyweights.

what would happen? Fedor would demolish Silva, fedor is untouchable at heavyweight frequently fighting people much bigger than he is, silva has been beaten and been in trouble against fighters who are much smaller than he is, fedor hits harder and would have little trouble taking silva to the ground, where his unparalleled ground and pound, or his submissions which are much better than silvas would finish the fight.