Flex track or Easy snap track for model trains?

Question

I just got started in Model Railroading, and have instantly become fond to it. But I don't know what I should get? Flex track or the Easy snap track? So far Im thinking Flex track...

Answer 1

I have been modeling N scale since 1968 and have really enjoyed the improvements that have been made.  Flex track has made modeling mounted layouts easier.  It does not work well for setting up a loose or unattached track for a few hours on the floor like we used to do around the Christmas tree.  The new snap track with molded bases works much better for temporary setups and small permanent layouts.  

I have found on larger layouts (more than a 4'x8' size) that the less amount of joints with flex track reduces the amount of track related problems.  Be careful when connecting flex track in curves that the track is anchored well to maintain smooth flow and connection to the next piece.  Flex track allows you to be completely free to lay track where you want it, and not have to design around the limits of snap track sizes.

Answer 2

I suggest flextrack. You can make any radius with it. I use it, and it's awesome. Might I also suggest using Atlas track? If it's N scale, you have code 55 or 80. I dunno about HO or higher.

Answer 3

Flex track is best if you're able to work with it. It will give you more flexibility because you're not limited to curves with fixed radii. If you lay it properly, you will have fewer derailments because you will have fewer joints between sections of track.  On the other hand, laying flex track takes more skill because you have to cut the track to fit. You probably will need to file and solder to make good joints. And flex track is more or less permanent, so you can't rearrange it as easily as you could with sectional track. If flex track isn't right for you, get the better quality sectional track from Atlas or Bachmann that comes with a base. Aside from looking better, the base helps keep the rails aligned properly, which minimizes derailments. Stay away from cheap snap track, it will just give you headaches.

Answer 4

I'm nearing retirement and planning a large layout when I do have the time for it.  Right now I am using what ever is in the train sets I buy, either Life-like Power-loc or Bachmann E-Z Track.  I joined several Yahoo Groups and have studied their layouts in which they laid their own track .  This looked like it would take too much time for me to do so I am going to stick to my snap tracks.  I will have much more time creating scenes and building models and running the trains.  I am now looking for pre-made tables because my carpentry skills are not that good.

For you, I would suggest joining some of these groups.  They post pics and videos, and have lots of experience they are willing to share.  If there are local clubs or shows in your area, stop in and see what is going on.  The people doing the shows are great at sharing their knowledge.

Answer 5

Well, that all depends ... do you want to build a big/small permanent layout, or just lay track every so often on a board to run trains? Do you want a realistic-looking railroad, or convenience in setting up and tearing down? Snap-track is good for space-limited people, or people who haven't decided what to create yet. Flextrack is better for a more realistic-looking railroad, but will require a more permanent installation to function properly. If you want to think "modular", there are  2' x 4' module clubs where you build a 2 foot by 4 foot "layout"  to a standard track spec ( 5" and 7"  track centers from the front edge ), which allows you to join up with other peoples modules to form a huge, wandering layout. Another concept is similar, called Free-mo, or freeform module, which uses the module concept, but allows you more freedom as to shape, size, etc.  That's if you want a socialized train atmosphere. If you are just building for yourself at home, you could do it modular to have the best of both worlds, take it with you to shows, etc. or just leave it set up at home, and it will also be easy to tear down and ship to move if necessary, due to it's small size compared to a large, permanent layout. Or a shelf layout if you're REALLY pinched for space.

Bottom line is, it all depends on your situation as to permanent or temporary, large space or small, etc. Since you didn't say, it's hard to give you good advice. All you can do is study the options, and pick which works for you best. For space-limited situations, and non-permanent installations, snap-track is probably best. If you have the room, money, and time for a permanent layout, then flex-track is your best bet for realism. Good luck, and welcome to Model Railroading!

- The Gremlin Guy -

www.pwmrc.org ( Virginia modular and permanent layout railroad club )