Fntasy foball?

Question

who should my back up QB be Jason Campbell or Eli Manning?

Answer 1

I would say Campbell. Eli Manning did not win the Superbowl for the Giants, the Giants defense did. Eli manning can be good at times but he is not consistent at all! He will throw 3 td's one game and 5 int's the next. He also takes a lot of sacks, and the Giants loove to run, especially down at the goal line with their bruiser Brandon Jacobs.

Campbell on the other hand just got the 2 best rookie WR's in the draft, along with Santana moss and of course Cooley (TD machine). And not to mention Clinton Portis is a receiving back, so he gets a lot of receptions that lead to TD's. Campbell led his team to the playoffs, and performed no worse than Manning, his defense just sucked.

Answer 2

I think you have to look at the matchups.

Being from the same division, they will play very similar schedules.

They actually are pretty even QBs when it comes to playing the position.

If it were me, I would ask myself which QB is going to find his team coming from behind, making him pass more.

That I think would be Campbell, just because their defense is much weaker.

When the Giants get a lead, they run, run, run.

Doesn't help Manning's stats.

Answer 3

Definitly Eli Manning, Super Bowl MVP and his recievers are starting to fit in. He has good TE's, good line, good recievers. Whats not to like.

Answer 4

Eli Manning..Jason Campbell isnt very good in the NFL. He is injury prone.

Answer 5

Lots of things favor Eli Manning:

- more durable then Campbell

- better receivers

- sure fire nr.1 QB on team (no Todd Collins lurking)

- more experience, mojo from SB win, known for comebacks

- more fantasy points per season

- according to wonderlic test twice as intelligent as Campbell (do not take this one too seriously)

Eli is a far better backup with potential to emerge as a true nr. 1 QB this season!