Football - Is this a Fair Trade??

Question

Need to Upgrade at TE.

Is this a Fair Trade to Offer?

I Give: K. Warner, G. Olsen

I GET: J. Witten

Keep in mind......HIS Team (The J. Witten Owner) has V. Young, J. Facco and B. Quinn as his QBs in a 2-Start QB league

Here's My Team:

12-Team H2H League Non-Keeper Standard Scoring

Start the Following - We Start 2 QBs!!!

2 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1K, 1 DEF, 6 BN

QB - D. Brees, B. Roethlisberger

RB - L. Tomlinson, Jamal Lewis

WR - Calvin Johnson, J. Cotchery, Santana Moss

TE - G. Olsen

K - M. Crosby

BN - K. Warner, E. James, C. Johnson (TEN), R. Rice, D. Stallworth, R. Meachem

DEF - Dallas

Thanks!

Answer 1

If I were him, I wouldn't take it. Yeah, his QBs suck, but it is not worth coughing up a star for a maybe fix at QB. The fact is, if he really wants to upgrade at QB, he'll be able to make a better trade than that. Doesn't hurt to ask him, though, in case he's an idiot!

Good luck!

Answer 2

go for it if i was offering that and if he accepted that i would of got a good trade

Answer 3

If we were talking about someone like Jeremy Shockey, Kellon Winslow, or Antonio Gates I'd call it a fair trade. However, Greg Olsen isn't any of those 3 players. Besides, they'd(the J. Witten owner) never take that trade.

Answer 4

given what you have and what he has that is a great trade both ways  

Answer 5

Awesome trade go for it...Witten is the best TE in the league hands down and to give up Warner and Olsen when you're that deep with good QBs, you'll definitely benefit.