For Motocross enthusiasts, is James Stewart better than Ricky Carmichael?

Question

For Motocross enthusiasts, is James Stewart better than Ricky Carmichael?

Answer 1

I think that the answer to that question will have to wait for a few years and then it will answer itself.  RC is brilliant no doubt but James Stewart is a star and will be someone who will be remembered as brilliant.  Just how many Championships he racks up is still to be seen.  Both of them are at different stages of their career so you are comparing completely different things.   So we shall have to wait and see!

Answer 2

this is a hard question. As of NOW ricky has more championships and more wins. however it would take some sort of miracle to stop james stewart from breaking his records. by 2015 James will be the new goat. everyone in the media agress his speed is way beyound rickys.

Answer 3

No way! Ricky is the GOAT; the greatest of all time.  There can only be ONE GOAT, and all time is forever.  James Stewart may be the most talented rider to ever through a leg over a motocycle, But Ricky puts in the most effort out there and thats why he is better than JS.

Answer 4

No, and he never will be.

Answer 5

NOBODY WILL EVER BE BETTER THAN THE G.O.A.T!!!!

Answer 6

In my opinion NO.

Answer 7

JS still has a long way to go to beat the all time records of Ricky.

What Ricky did was like was Mick Doohan did in the 500cc Grand Prix.

Will James do what Vale Rossi then did in the MotoGP ........ we will have to wait and see.

More the question would be, how great would it be to see them race together , both in there prime ??