For Shiites,how can we know that you are not using Taqqiyah?

Question

meaning how can we know whether you are liars or telling the truth?

if i had a shiite who claims to be my friend,how can I be sure of that he is not a hidden enemy who is waiting a chance to harm?!!

Answer 1

Taqiyya is 9/10 of the shiaism religion

Answer 2

Shia people can only lie if their life was in danger !i

Answer 3

Taqqiyah is a sign of a Mumin, but you wouldn't know anything about that would you. And another thing this question can be answered from the Quran when he told you not to doubt a person unless you have solid proof. Doe to start teaching you guys the Quran, have you read this verse before, if you haven't, know you know.

O ye who believe! avoid much suspicion; for suspicion in some cases is a sin. And spy not on one another, neither back-bite one another. Would any of you like to eat the flesh of his dead brother? Certainly, you would loath it. And fear Allah, surely, Allah is oft-Returning with compassion and is Merciful. (49:12 Quran)

That said, i know Sunni are so perfect, that they never lie, they are basically infallible, aren't you?

Edit: Let me tell you how it is a sign of a Mumin, when a Jew comes to cause fitna between Muslims, and you hear him say Shia are not Muslims, what would you as a Sunni Muslim reply to him?

Or when the Prophet (s) at the beginning of his Mission before he publicly declared Islam, was he practicing Taqiyah or was he being a hypocrite istaghfurallah? Or when he signed the treaty with the Kuffar, did he not sign his name as Muhammad without adding the messenger of Allah, was that not Taqiyah? your problems you do not know what Taqiya is. I will prov e to you from the Quran:

Whoso disbelieves in Allah after he has believed - save him who is forced to make a declaration of disbelief while his heart finds peace in faith - but such as open their breast to disbelief, on them is Allah's wrath; and for them is decreed a severe punishment. (16:106)

So explain this verse for me then?

Well if you agree the practice of Taqiyya is permitted if there is definite danger facing one's own life or other innocent Muslims, then why are you argueing about it. Your problem is you do not know the rules of Taqiyah, you just listen from here and there and come and ask, instead of searching from shia sites what Taqiya is, you will find that Sunni use it and part ,of their religion to.

Answer 4

What do you mean by Taqyiah and what do you know about it ?

Have a closer look at Koran and read the story of Abraham (Koran-chapter 37):

"And from among his descendants was Abraham. For he came to his Lord with a pure heart.When he said to his father and his people: "What are you worshiping?"

Is it fabricated gods, instead of God, that you want?"

What do you say of the Lord of the worlds?"

Then he looked towards the stars.

And he said: "I am ill!" So they turned away from him and departed ..."

You see ,He said he was ill, while he wasn't ; They turned away and he shattered the idols except the big one !

You're also allowed to use it when you see your life in jeopardy :

Whoever rejects God after having believed; except for one who is forced while his heart is still content with belief; but the one who opens his chest to rejection, then they will have a wrath from God and they will have a great retribution. (Koran-16:106)

Lying is something else dude and we already know it's a great sin and god does not guide the liars.

Some groups are using your ignorance to structure your mind ; In order to avoid it , study and study and study .

Good luck.

Answer 5

Shias lies all the time ,without any emergency situation,

Muslim is also allowed to lie to safe his life .

They also blammed Ali (ra) ,that he gave pledge alligiance to first three caliphs as a Taqiyya.( naozobillah)

Answer 6

Al-Taqiyya is diplomacy.

Ibn Sa'd in his book, "al-Tabaqat al-Kubra," narrates on the authority of

Ibn Sirin that:

The Prophet (s) saw `Ammar Ibn Yasir (ra) crying, so he wiped off his tears, and said: "The nonbelievers arrested you and immersed you in water until you said such and such (i.e., bad-mouthing the Prophet (s) and praising the pagan gods to escape persecution); if they come back, then say it again."

Abu al-Darda' said:

"(Verily) we smile for some people, while our hearts curse (those same people)."

Sahih al-Bukhari, v7, p102

The Prophet (s)

said:

"O `Aisha, the worst of people in the sight of Allah (SWT) are those

that are avoided by others due to their extreme impudence."

Sahih al-Bukhari, v7, p81,

The meaning here is that one is permitted to use diplomacy to get along with people. The above tradition was narrated when a person sought permission to see the Holy Prophet (s) and prior to his asking permission the Prophet (s) said that he was not a good man, but still I shall see him. The Prophet talked to the person with utmost respect, upon which Aisha inquired as to why did the Prophet (s) talk to the person with respect despite his character, upon which the above reply was rendered.

It becomes apparent after reading the above explenation that we all pactice Taqiyah.

Answer 7

o c'mon....shias dont hate sunnis...all  my friends are sunni...you think i am gonna kil them in the middle of the night??

seems like all you guys in this section have never practically had shia friends....

Answer 8

Warning:

"Cold as Ice", "sameer s", "eviwahhabi", "Mjaffery12", "Osama", "gunnerH", "csucmasy ", "FTL(Turba charged)", "Pro Actice", "shams" .

is the same user a Lebanese Shia

Answer 9

We may not know, but really, what good will it do us to know? What they do is their business....I'm sure none of us have perfected our own Iman, so why should we care excessively about the affairs of another group when we don't even care as much about our own problems?

Answer 10

How is taqiyah a sign of a mumin?

Answer 11

its ok buddy, i feel the exact same way about wahabis, i dont trust a word they say, nor will i trust my life with them, since their pretty good at blowing them selves up

Answer 12

Excellent question!

When somebody tells u lies several times, even if he tells u the truth after that, u can't believe him. How would u know if he is lying or telling the truth? U'd be thinking of the hadith:

"A momin (believer) can't be bitten twice from the same hole."

so, u'll simply reject his statement!

Even the Quran says: "O u believers! when a fasiq comes up to u with news, investigate"

And when it's a part of somebody's religious beliefs to lie, there is no telling what he's gonna say...

Answer 13

what are u talking about?