For fantasy baseball, Chase Headley or Mike Aviles?

Question

Who will contribute more to my team?

Answer 1

Chase Headley, he is playing in a hitter's park with some solid guys ahead of him.

Answer 2

Chase Headley does not play in a hitters park. PETCO is the best pitchers park in the league.

Still I would probably take Headley over Aviles. Headley is a top prospect and already has smacked two homeruns.

It matters what you need as well. Headley will be OF eligible soon as well because he has been playing some OF so thats a bonus.

If Headley starts heating up than trade him because you could probably get a lot for him. Look at Justin Upton in the month of April, if you traded him back then you could have got almost anyone you wanted.

Answer 3

Headley has the pedigree but Aviles is  proving all the skeptics (ie scouts) were very wrong about him.  He can surely hack and has played better than advertised defense.  Even though a lot of  fantasy managers aren't buying into him long term yet  I kind of have a gut feeling that he is legit....I think 12 homers and solid average (.280ish) and rbi production is what you can expect the rest of the way from him.  Headley will be a star but my view is that it won't happen this year....unless in a keeper league take Aviles...