For my birthday, I'm looking for a formal restaurant to go for dinner, but not way too expensive.?

Question

I'm looking for a restaurant around Setauket, NY or Port Jefferson NY; anywhere around their. Please help me find a restaurant, I've been looking for a while now and can't seem to find a good one. I need a restaurant that's fancy and formal/ semi formal, but not out of control expensive. Thanks so much!

Answer 1

i would say Olive Garden or johnny carinos, Olive Garden is better ;) (only if u like Italian)

Answer 2

do they an Olive Garden there?  they look nice and fairly cheap