Garrett Atkins & Roy Halladay for Alex Rodriguez?

Question

Who gets the better deal?

Answer 1

Halladay and Atkins, hands down.

Atkins has dual position eligibility, and Halladay has been Cy Young-like all season.

A-Rod is a huge talent, of course, but Atkins has the same amount of RBI and Runs scored as him.

A-Rod is no doubt the best 3B, but you're getting a huge bonus with Halladay.

Answer 2

i think the person who gave up atkins and halladay gave up too much for a-rod.