Getting my Security Deposit back?

Question

Let me start by saying we live in the SF Bay Area and the codo we rent is managed by a company not the owner.

We have been in our condo for over 5 years. When we moved in there were a ton of issues from the carpets having stains to the stove not working properly.

At the time the rental market was tight and we needed to move-in right away, so we took it as is.

Since then the carpet has deteriorated, the dishwasher (from the early 80's) does not run properly. The stove microwave (also from the early 80's) no longer works, the grout in the showers has peeled, ect, ect.

Now the landlord is sending us a bill for the amount they paid over the Security Deposit and we are saying they owe us money back.

We were there for over 5 years, there was existing problems when we moved in (and noted on our initial inspection), most items should be normal wear and tear, and the appliances are over 20 years old.

Who is right? What do I do? Who make the decision on what is normal wear and tear?

Answer 1

Tenants are normally not responsible for normal wear and tear, unless their lease expressly states it. I would document the issues as much as you can, and contact your local housing board or consumer protection agency.

Answer 2

all that sounds like normal wear and tear to me, especially after 5 years.

You can ONLY be charged for things that you specifically damaged.

Take them to court with your initial inspection report and you should be awarded your deposit back.