Giant, Electra, Specialized, Raleigh, Trek - which bike is best?

Question

I am TALL (5'10") and want a bike that is comfortable yet rugged enough to go "off-trail" - not like rocky, just able to take potholes. Since I have close to a 34-inch inseam - Im an 18 or 19 inch stem on bikes. I originally had a pink Huffy with flamingos on it - despite the color, it is nice. Ha ha.

I dont like skinny tires and dont need speed. I dont want a cruiser either (7 spd at least). I do like suspension in front (to ease the drops). Its hard to find bikes in my size, so I end up testing on men's bikes, which I hate.

I have test rode a Trek Navigator 2.0 (in mens), an Electra Townie 21 (mens and womens), Raleigh Venture 3.0 (womens), GIANT Sedona DX (mens and womens) and a Specialized Elite (mens) and Sport (womens).

Some shops dont seem to fit me on the bike right so I end up with my back hurting. So far the Specialized one has been good to me :) BUT now its decision time. Color is an issue too: black, silver, titanium are cool. Would love some opinions :) Thanks

Answer 1

5'10" isnt really that tall...

Answer 2

Id worry more about the correct fit, before the color! talk to the shop guys about fit. your back may be stretched too much if youre getting some pain. women's bikes have shorter toptubes, but also tend to have lower standover. try a shorter stem on a men's bike. youll get a larger frame, but can shorten your reach. with the range of bikes to choose from, with the brands you've listed alone, youre sure to find something! first go with the shop that's willing to take the time to fit you! then go with the bike that fits. then finally, see what color choices you have. usually, at this stage, you won't have too many color options, unless you're going higher end..

Answer 3

I just got a new Trek and I love it. Its the best bike I've ever owned.

Answer 4

if you are serious about buying a bike, most bike stores will let you take the bike for a day or 2 to try it out.  i have a cannondale road bike which i love and a specialized hybrid which is ok.  many people like trek.  i liked cannondale better than trek.  just try it out until you find a fit and feel you like.