Giants Fans: Who is Worse: Walker, or Benitez?

Question

I say Benitez

he had like 40 blown saves

Answer 1

Benitez without a doubt. He got injured in 2005, and after he came back he sucked. He blew so many saves, and was a terrible pitcher. I don't like Walker anymore as well. I liked him at the starting of th season, but he is pitching so badly, that whenever he comes out to pitch, I just feel like smashing the tv.

Answer 2

Benitez. The guy seems to enjoy blowing saves after another. Walker had some good appearances at the bullpen but once Benitez was on the mound, you knew something bad would happen.

Answer 3

I say Benitez also, for the exact same reason.

Answer 4

BENITEZ!

Enough said...

Answer 5

As much as Id like to say Benitez Im going with walker because he's still on the Giants. Honestly if Bochy runs him out there again he should be fired. Tyler Walker is fat and out of shape and all he does is serve up fastballs down the middle. Get rid of him please

Answer 6

obviously Benitez

Answer 7

They are both equally as bad. Tyler Walker just can't seem to have an inning in which he doesn't give up runs. Lincecum should have a few more wins. Sabean isn't a very intelligent GM. Some of the things he does confuses the h**l out of me. Not signing Bonds again while he wants to play is a mistake. I don't care about any controversy surrounding him. He can still hit and he has the ability to help out any team. A new GM might bring a little more success. He let Schmidt walk so the Giants got nothing for him, the Aaron Rowand and Bengie Molina acquisitions were great, but as the answer above me said, not even Tampa Bay wanted Walker. The Benitez deal was stupid as well. Yes, their team is doing bad, but I blame their GM.

Answer 8

Oh God, it is like trying to choose which one sucks less. in that case it should be Blownitez since he blew a ton of saves in his years with the giants.  

Answer 9

Hmmm, thats difficult to answer.  Hmmm, ermm, I will have to go with Benitez with Walker a close second, or maybe a photo finish.

Answer 10

I agree with you, Benitez.

Answer 11

Benitez is the ultimate worse no matter what team he plays for.

Answer 12

Tyler Walker is, without a doubt, the biggest joke to ever wear a Giants uniform.  I sincerely hate the guy.  I used to scream "NO!" when he would hit the warmup mound back when they FIRST had him.  Keep in mind that he was so horrible that the Giants dumped him to the Devil Rays, who at the time was the WORST team in baseball, and even they dropped him down to the minors.  Then, what do the Giants do?  Well, pick him back up, of course!

I really hate that guy.