Gilmore or waters ?????????????

Question

which pink floyd gilmore or waters

(personally i think gilmore is the best he made the band, with his own unique sound on guitar)

Answer 1

i saw pink floyd more years ago than i'd care to say and, in my opinion, david gilmore's guitar made the sound so much deeper and richer.

on a personal level i've heard and read that d.g.'s ego is huge and it's his way or the highway.

by the way, sid barrett made the band but too much pressure and too many acid trips did him in.

Answer 2

Gilmore IS Pink Floyd. Take away Waters, It's still Pink Floyd. Take away Gilmore, they'd have to dis-band.