Goal or No Goal?

Question

which of these are goals

1.http://blogs.newsobserver.com/media/commodore.JPG

2.http://img185.imageshack.us/img185/7131/nhl20072006122321544481yx6.png

3.http://www4.pictures.gi.zimbio.com/Edmonton+Oilers+v+Chicago+Blackhawks+uUdKEApJj_8l.jpg

4.http://columbiainferno.com.ismmedia.com/ISM3/std-content/repos/Top/Blog%20pictures/Jan%204%2008/IMG_4134.JPG

5.http://cache.daylife.com/imageserve/01XAdqPgrt3N1/610x.jpg

Answer 1

Number one

number three is close.

Answer 2

number 1

Answer 3

Well 1 is a goal

2 is a video game but 2-4 look like they could easily become goals. 5 is the only one that looks like even with momentum it won't be a goal.

Answer 4

Number 1 is the only definite goal

Answer 5

one

Answer 6

Number one, even a blind person can determine that is in the net.I would like to add, whoever makes the decision about if it's a goal or not a goal, should be fired.How many times have the called off goals that are clearly in the net...

Answer 7

1.http://blogs.newsobserver.com/media/comm... the only goal.....in all other shots, the "entire" puck is not over the line as per rules.

Answer 8

#1

Answer 9

2 throuh 4 are not goals yet... not completely over the line.

1 Looks like it may be  but with the snow build up it is hard to tell.  If it is not a goal it could be a penalty shot.  That is a skaters glove covering it in the crease if it is not in.

Answer 10

1, but 3 would send me into cardiac arrest

Answer 11

Only number 1, for it to bee a goal the Whole puck has to be across the goaline.

Answer 12

Hi

Number one was the only one that had a angle showing the puck clearly over the line.  while that doesn't take into account when the whistle was or intent to blow the whistle or any other factors.  Just purely over the line is number one.

Thank You

Answer 13

Assuming that the puck had come to complete stops on all 4 of your examples then #1 is the only goal.

Answer 14

1. Goal

2. No goal

3. No goal

4. No goal

5. No goal

Answer 15

Number one, only one where the entire puck is over the goal line.

Answer 16

# 1

Answer 17

The only goal is the first one.

Answer 18

just 1

Answer 19

Two through five are 100% not goals.

Number one, from the angle provided, is the most likely of the list.  I want to see it from a different angle before I absolutely declare it a goal.  It's late in whichever period it happened and it's not easy to tell whether it is still touching the line.

Answer 20

The only conclusive goal is #1

#2 shows the shadow of the puck clearly proving that the puck is not over the red line yet.

In #'s 3-5, the puck does not cross the entire red line.

Answer 21

1 2 and 3 in my opinion!

Answer 22

just 1) because the puck has to be COMPLETELY OVER THE LINE

Answer 23

All of them except number 5 (the Tampa Bay goaltender and the puck one).