Good or bad? The trade for Ivan Rodriguez to the Yankees for Kyle Farnsworth to the Tigers?

Question

Good or bad? The trade for Ivan Rodriguez to the Yankees for Kyle Farnsworth to the Tigers?

Answer 1

GREAT trade for the Yanks. Got a veteran future Hall of Fame catcher to spell Posada for two months and got rid of an inconsistent reliever who can easily be replaced. Edwar Ramirez should be good enough that the Yanks won't miss Farnsworth.  

Answer 2

Great trade for the Yanks.  On top of getting a decent catcher, they got rid of a crappy reliever.

Answer 3

Bad trade for the Tigers.

Answer 4

c**p for c**p IMO

Answer 5

Good for the Yankees. Bad for the Tigers (What's new?)

Answer 6

Extremely lopsided in the Yankees favor.

How can a reliver who might pitch 30 innings the rest of the year match the value of a great hitting catcher ?  

Answer 7

Ivan is better but kyle is like 7 years younger  

Answer 8

Awesome for the Yankme's but for the Tigs I'm gonna have to say no

Answer 9

Both teams will not make the playoffs so maybe its an even trade.

Answer 10

The Yanks made a great trade, while the Tigers made one of their worst trades in franchise history.

Answer 11

tigers gave up too much for just Farnsworth

Answer 12

In between.