Good or bad trade???

Question

i give hamels, maine and mcclouth

i get JD Drew, Tejada

my pitchers now are cliff lee, ervin santana, lackey, the harangatang, wagner, valverde, sherrill, rauch then hamels and maine who i would be giving up

i need a ss cuz quite frankly im sick of renteria's inconsistency

JD Drew has been a beast so if he can keep that up thats great...my outfielders now are ichiro, magglio, beltran, and mcclouth

GOOD or BAD trade?

Answer 1

This is a pretty good trade. You get two awesome players, but give up Hamels, who's one of the most consistent pitchers, and McClouth, who's a potential all-star. You'll live without Maine, because you've got pretty good starting pitchers to replace them, and I think Drew should be a good replacement for McClouth. And it looks like your outfield is really good. Tejada's an excellent replacement for Renteria, so I think it's worth it. This is a rare trade where it could benefit both teams. Do the trade.

Answer 2

Man, in my opinion, you're getting robbed. Lord knows that JD Drew is always on the verge of hitting the DL.