Good trade for them or me?

Question

i lost jerry porter and peterson min

i got brian westbrook and now my running back team is brandon jacobs and westbrook

and i didnt lose much wr wise cause i still have williams braylon edwards and andre johnson

Answer 1

Bad deal for you because AP is typically being taken 2nd and sometimes 1st overall. Not to mention you gave him a potential #1 wr in Porter.

He won that deal. You should never trade before camp starts because the guy/guys you end up getting tend to get hurt.

The guys that says Porter has a crappy QB throwing to him is on crack. Garrard could very well throw 25 or more td's this year. He threw 18 last year and missed a few games. He also had horrible wr's last year and now he has 2 new targets to throw at.

Porter could very well have a 70 catch 1000 yard 8 td season ahead of him

Answer 2

not a good deal basically you lost Peterson for Westbrook it may have not hurt your team but it may have helped his . Peterson has the best o-line in football

Answer 3

Good deal for you. Westbrook will rack up more touchdowns and receiving yards then AP. Porter has a crappy QB throwing to him and you already have a good receiving game without him.

Answer 4

I see it as a great deal b/c Jp is not very good. and you picked up brian witch is solid and Jacobs if he dont get hurt stud i would back him up with bradshaw just in case though i thank its a good deal on both ends i dont see a loser here..