Gore for Barber or Jackson?

Question

A guy in my league really wants Frank Gore..he is offering either barber or jackson

Which should I take

Answer 1

Of those three, I believe Barber to be the best option. Gore is good, but on an offense that has little else to it. Jackson missed almost all of the preseason, except for a week of conditioning the final week after his hold-out. I expect him to start slowly, maybe eventually reaching his potential in a month or two.

Barber is on one of the most potent offenses in the league. And, he'll get his touches - and opportunities to score. And, even if the Cowboys do put up lots of points passing, they're going to go to the ground to eat away the clock.

I would pick up Barber.

Answer 2

Steven Jackson is better

I'd rather have Barber than Gore too...

Answer 3

I would take Barber or Jackson for Gore, however, out of the 2 I would take Barber without question.  

Jackson and Barber are no doubt both very good players and will have good years.  The difference i think will be that St. Louis just isn't the offense they once were so Jackson will have a much tougher time getting the yards and tds that the Saint Louis backs are used to getting.  Plus,  Dallas is going to be a scoring machine this year and you thought Barber was nice last year, he is the starter now.  And in that offense, I personally think he will blow Jackson away in fantasy points.  

Answer 4

Jackson 4 sure