Greatest Baseball Player Brackett Round 5?

Question

First Round Results:

Jackie Robinson (8-3) defeats Tony Gwynn

Ken Griffey Jr. (9-1) defeats Rickey Henderson

Yogi Berra (8-3) defeats Josh Gibson

Ted Williams (9-1) defeats Reggie Jackson

Willie Mays (10-0) defeats Harmon Killenbrew

Pete Rose (9-2) defeats Willie McCovey

George Sisler (7-4) defeats Duke Snider

Roberto Clemente (10-1) defeats Tris Speaker

Cal Ripken Jr. (8-3) defeats Mike Schmidt

Stan Musial (7-4) defeats Roger Hornsby

Lou Gehrig (9-2) defeats Honus Wagner

Ty Cobb (8-2) defeats Johnny Bench

Babe Ruth (10-1) defeats Barry Bonds

Mickey Mantle (10-1) defeats George Brett

Mel Ott (7-3) defeats Carl Yastremski

Joe DiMaggio (9-2) defeats Frank Robinson

Second Round Results:

Roberto Clemnte (7-2) defeats Yogi Berra

Babe Ruth (9-0) defeats George Sisler

Lou Gehrig (6-3) defeats Joe DiMaggio

Mickey Mantle (7-2) defeats Jackie Robinson

Ken Griffey Jr. (9-0) defeats Mel Ott

Willie Mays (9-0) defeats Cal Ripken Jr.

Ted Williams (6-3) defeats Ty Cobb

Pete Rose (6-3) defeats Stan Musial

Round 3 results

Willie Mays (8-0) defeats Pete Rose

Babe Ruth (8-0) defeats Ken Griffey Jr

Ted Williams (5-3) defeats Lou Gehrig

Mickey Mantle (6-2) defeats Roberto Clemente

Round 4:

Babe Ruth (6-0) defeats Ted Williams

Willie Mays (6-0) defeats Mickey Mantle

FINAL MATCHUP

Babe Ruth vs. Willie Mays

Answer 1

Babe Ruth

Answer 2

Willie Mays was a much better overall player

In other words a 5 tool player  

Answer 3

Willie Mays, the Say Hey Kid.

Better all-around player than Babe.

Answer 4

The Big Bambino The Sultan of swat

George Herman "Babe" Ruth

Answer 5

babe ruth...surprised no one voted for mantle at all against mays

Answer 6

Willie Mays

Answer 7

As great as Mays was as a player, he didn't reinvent the game.

Vote goes to Ruth.

I'm utterly shocked that in round 2, 6 people thought Rose was better than Musial

Answer 8

William Mays

Answer 9

Willie Mays

he is better overall

i would have voted for ted williams over the babe

Answer 10

Ruth