Greatest Red Sox Tournament Round 2?

Question

Babe Ruth vs. Manny Ramirez

Tris Speaker vs. Jim Rice

Pedro Martinez vs. Bobby Doerr

Ted Williams vs. Fred Lynn

Joe Cronin vs. Nomar Garciapara

Carlton Fisk vs. Dwight Evans

Curt Schilling vs. Rico Perrocelli

Carl Yastremski vs. Jim Longborn

Vote on who wisn each matchup in terms of what they did in the yrs w/the Red Sox

Answer 1

Manny

Rice

Doerr

Ted W.

Cronin

Fisk

Curt

Yaz

Answer 2

Manny

Jim

Pedro

Ted

Nomar

Carlton

Curt

Carl

Answer 3

Everyone who is picking Rice over Speaker doesn't know a lot about the history of baseball.  Speaker has something like a career .344 batting average and 700 something steals.  He was considered the best CF in the game when he played.  This post isn't to denigrate those who have picked Rice, it's just to give a little education on Tris Speaker.  He's a Hall of Famer.  Rice isn't.  That should be enough right there.

Answer 4

tough one man.

Manny

Speaker

Petey

Ted

Cronin, Nomar... nevermind... kids might see this

really tearing at heart strings here bro... Fisk if I have to choose

Schill... just cause he has brought us 2 WS, that's the only reason.

Yaz

edit: person above me... Jim Rice should be in the Hall of Fame...  but agreed.

Speaker won 2 WS with the Red Sox... Rice went to two...Speaker played in the dead ball era, Rice lost some good years before he got that eye test. They both played in a famous Red Sox outfields.

Answer 5

Babe Ruth,

Jim Rice

Pedro Martinez

Ted Williams

Joe Cronin

Carlton Fisk

Curt Schilling

Carl Yastremski

GO JAYS!

Answer 6

Babe Ruth

Jim Rice

Pedro Martinez

Ted Williams

Joe Cronin

Carlton Fisk

Curt Schilling

Yaz

Answer 7

Manny Ramirez

Jim Rice

Pedro Martinez

Ted Williams

Joe Cronin

Carlton Fisk

Curt Schilling

Carl Yastremski

Answer 8

Babe Ruth

Jim Rice

Pedro Martinez

Ted Williams

Nomar Garciaparra

Carlton Fisk

Curt Shilling

Yaz

Answer 9

Manny (Ruth is a tratior!)

Rice

Martinez

Ted Williams

Nomar

Fisk

Ol' Bloody Sock

Yaz

Answer 10

Just give the title to Ted Williams, its really not even that close.