Guitar or Piano?

Question

I've gotten a lot more interested in music over the past year or so, I like singing and I want to take up either the guitar or the piano, I'd like to learn them both eventually. I took piano lessons for about five years, but was never really that good at it, probably because never really put the effort into it because I wasn't as interested in music at the time. So I would have a little head start at re-learning the piano, but do you think I should try for the guitar or the piano first?

Answer 1

Since you already have a background in piano, Id start there, and then work in the guitar a little later.

Answer 2

go for the piano you can learn fast master it then you can focus and practice on the guitar later

Answer 3

Well, I was told that I should learn piano first and then guitar. Do you know how to read music sheets? well, if you do then i think you should go for guitar. I dont know but I think guitar is a little better its harder but i think its better. Good luck,

tell me how it goes!

Answer 4

If you've already studied piano for five years, you've probably picked up a reasonable basis in musical theory.

A guitar is one heck of a lot more portable than the (only a parlour size) grand piano I have sitting in my little living room.

Answer 5

piano's better. guitar is too hard. plus you allready took piano for a long time

Answer 6

piano.

It is awesome.

Plus if you learn to read music for the piano then reading music for the guitar is easier. I once heard someone say that the piano is the first instruments anyone interested in music should learn, and I agree.