Hamels or Padilla?

Question

i have both starters going today. i think i should start padilla just because he is doing really well this year and the phillies are really slumping. but i want some other opinions on who to start

Answer 1

is there some reason you can't play both.  Yea i know they are facing each other but i think it'll be a pitchers duel.  If i had to choose one i'd probably have to go with Padilla right now becuase the phillies are in a serious slump

Answer 2

Padilla has to come back to the planet. Hamels has too many skills. But is there some reason that you can not start both in your league?

Good luck. Have fun.

Answer 3

An ordinary day I would go with Hamels but the phillies are finding out that the AL is heads and shoulders above what they usually see so I would ride everyone who plays philly now from the AL until they can show that they can beat them...

Answer 4

wow... such a dilemma you're in right now. and to think both of them will be facing their opponents for the first time in their career.

But I will go with Hamels on this one because the Phillies has already seen the good and the bad side of Padilla when he pitched for them for six seasons (2001-2005) so somehow, they already seen all his pitches and I'm pretty sure that the Phillies batters will figure out on how to hit them.

also it will be another high-scoring game just like what happened last night.