Has anyone tried elf waterproof liquid eyeliner?

Question

I've read reviews that say it smells really bad but someone said it rivals the quality of MAC's eyeliner. Would you be concerned about the smell, especially considering it's $1? Would you try it anyway?

Answer 1

no i would just use something like bare escentuals which is really pretty and can be worn all day. just becasue it is cheap doesn't mean you should get it. it probably will run and is not waterproof because the price is so low.

Answer 2

It's awesome!!! I've tried it! It doesn't last all day, but it'll last a good 5 hours or so. My sister has UD Primer Potion and it lasts over 8 hours. It's so worth it and I love this brand.

Answer 3

Well I have it and I really like it I t has a fine tip on it so you can get good application plus I've heard really great reviews on it and besides its only one dollar what do you have to loose?

Answer 4

nope

it might cause irritation

Answer 5

I would, smell doesn't really concern me, unless it's way too strong.