Has anyone whom had a question taken down by Y/A ever get it back up?

Question

Especially in certain sections like politics. Now I know Y/A will take down questions that didn't break the rules and when you appeal say you broke the rules but has anyone been told that Y/A was in error? I think it's all automated and will automatically say you in violation no matter what or how stupid the reason is, even if it was the most idiodic reason you could think of or didn't even apply.

I recently got one for "not a question or answer", I appealed and 3-4 minutes later got the automated message that I was in violation. But it did fit the dictionary definition of a question but it was asked about certain other accounts, but the thing is they used "not a question or answer" tells me their pandering or just don't care to take a second look.

I'd like to talk directly in person to the people whom decide what right and wrong. It's like how youtube would remove accounts of people critical of islam.

Answer 1

once.

I asked "Does anyone have any shaving tips or tricks?"

They said it was not a question

I said it was, and it got put back up

but that was on a different account

Answer 2

No, Y! Answers can be a******s about censorship sometimes.

Answer 3

Good point.  I've never had an appeal overturned.